Romantic/Relaxing Get-away...Which Island?

[anonymus]

My boyfriend and I are planning a vacation for Feb 17-21, 2004. We are trying to narrow down which Island we want to go to, but it is extremely hard!!

I need help.

What we are looking for:
1. Relaxing (gorgeous beaches, mountains, etc.)
2. Romantic (not over-crowded, party scene at night is not important)
3. Activities during the day such as fishing or snorkeling.
4. Nothing as expensive as Turks & Caicos.
5. Is an "all-inclusive" resort worth it.

Thank you and I appreciate any response.

[anonymus]

Cayman sounds like a good choice for you, particularly the North Shore....as for all inclusives, all depends on your personal preference....

[anonymus]

bvi is my choice. virgin gorda is great. try levrick bay resort quiet & not too pricey

[anonymus]

This is a romantic place. We celebrate our anniversary there and it was terrific and excellent service. The restaurant "Simba" is top notch, too. Right on a gorgeous part of the beach and by the snorkeling reef.

[dmharris]

So where did you end up going in 2004 and is your boyfriend now your husband?? A test to the true romantic quality of your destination, no?